PS3 Roster Consolidation

As MANIC suggested I am opening a new poll/topic for consideration.

In my opinion, roster I should ALWAYS have 100 on it. Then roster II should have 100. So on so forth. Just my opinion.

Roster I - 78
Roster II - 72
Roster III - 37

So by using my wonderful math skills, if roster I had 100, roster II would have 87 with 13 extra spots and no need for roster III. What does everyone think about consolidation? If in the event we did this, and by some miracle, I made it to roster I, Repo could lead roster II.

Agree.

well you wouldnt want someone to get more than their fair share of double xp. If it would even do that to begin with

I don't think it matters one way or the other. The ones of us that play together do so regardless of what rosters we r on because we are all 30's. What i think might be the problem later or maybe already is dead weight that is taking up roster spots that never plays at all.

I think it makes sense to consolidate the rosters. It would be easier for the moderators to manage. As far as Elite goes, wouldn't consolidating the rosters increase the pool for a top 6 for the Clan Operations?

How would the consolidation be organized? Would roster 3 simply be absorbed into the other 2 rosters or would the 1st 22 in Roster 2 be moved to Roster 1 and all of Roster 3 moved to Roster 2?

wait, was I not supposed to vote FBD is a prick? I don't see any real reason not to consolidate. I would venture to say that most of us non OGs but non super new guys would love to be on R1 BUT it doesn't really matter since we all end up playing together anyway. not like R2 and 3 are full of slouches. We play with whomever has space, plain and simple.

Hey Dave, I did just notice though, I'm listed in the Roster 1 usergroup as well as the Roster 2 group.

WISC-YETI wrote:

I think it makes sense to consolidate the rosters. It would be easier for the moderators to manage. As far as Elite goes, wouldn't consolidating the rosters increase the pool for a top 6 for the Clan Operations?

How would the consolidation be organized? Would roster 3 simply be absorbed into the other 2 rosters or would the 1st 22 in Roster 2 be moved to Roster 1 and all of Roster 3 moved to Roster 2?

It makes sense to keep maintaining the lists so the active people are on the clans. Maybe we move dead weight to Roster III until they are just cut off?

And I would think people would move up by join date?

walldoggy wrote:

WISC-YETI wrote:

I think it makes sense to consolidate the rosters. It would be easier for the moderators to manage. As far as Elite goes, wouldn't consolidating the rosters increase the pool for a top 6 for the Clan Operations?

How would the consolidation be organized? Would roster 3 simply be absorbed into the other 2 rosters or would the 1st 22 in Roster 2 be moved to Roster 1 and all of Roster 3 moved to Roster 2?

It makes sense to keep maintaining the lists so the active people are on the clans. Maybe we move dead weight to Roster III until they are just cut off?

And I would think people would move up by join date?

Agreed, by join date

Walldog...interesting concept. Let's keep that thought burning brightly.

I'd throw in also that agree with by date but don't forget about forum activity.

JBings wrote:

I'd throw in also that agree with by date but don't forget about forum activity.

+1 to forum activity. You could have someone that joined roster II, hasn't played since they joined, and haven't posted ANYTHING moved to roster I.

I would like to submit a write in vote for boobs...

hoffyguns wrote:

I would like to submit a write in vote for boobs...

i think it's sad boobs are no longer on the votes, just something about a prick.

walldoggy wrote:

WISC-YETI wrote:

I think it makes sense to consolidate the rosters. It would be easier for the moderators to manage. As far as Elite goes, wouldn't consolidating the rosters increase the pool for a top 6 for the Clan Operations?

How would the consolidation be organized? Would roster 3 simply be absorbed into the other 2 rosters or would the 1st 22 in Roster 2 be moved to Roster 1 and all of Roster 3 moved to Roster 2?

It makes sense to keep maintaining the lists so the active people are on the clans. Maybe we move dead weight to Roster III until they are just cut off?

And I would think people would move up by join date?

i agree with this too, as i had mentioned in an earlier thread chris, there are alot of guys on the roster II that i don't even see on this forum, and not really sure if they are active players. you should clean house like dave did with the forums, free up roster space for guys who are actively playing with the clan.

I think consolidation would be good, esp. it if amounts to double XP for both rosters. Definitely agree consideration should be given to join date & forum activity. When all is said & done, I'll play with people on my FL and whoever has room in a party. and I vote for BOOBS.

Fucking Elite and it's limit cap bullshit...as well as PS

I agree consolidation should occur. On a side note patience must be had, as it is a metric shit-ton of work for Dave to remove people from elite and send out invites to get them onto the new roster. Plus he will have to figure out who to add from II to I and III to II. I do think join date is the primary requirement to join, but forum activity is critical also. I would hate to skip a guy on roster III who is active on the forum and PS3 in favor of a roster II guy who hardley ever plays with the clan and never posts up here in this hellhole of debauchery.

I would add, besides boobs,

Roster I should be the 30’s that want to do Clan stuff on Elite. I thought I read about clan challenges being collective achievements that everyone in the clan needs to do.

Roster II could be “regular/active” 30’s that play but not really into Elite Clan stuff.

Roster III – noobs & inactive folks

Dead_Eric wrote:

Roster I should be the 30’s that want to do Clan stuff on Elite. I thought I read about clan challenges being collective achievements that everyone in the clan needs to do.

Roster II could be “regular/active” 30’s that play but not really into Elite Clan stuff.

Roster III – noobs & inactive folks

this is a great idea eric, if we go this route, put me on roster I, cause i am down with helping out this clan with Elite.

BigDaddyN8 wrote:

I agree consolidation should occur. On a side note patience must be had, as it is a metric shit-ton of work for Dave to remove people from elite and send out invites to get them onto the new roster. Plus he will have to figure out who to add from II to I and III to II. I do think join date is the primary requirement to join, but forum activity is critical also. I would hate to skip a guy on roster III who is active on the forum and PS3 in favor of a roster II guy who hardley ever plays with the clan and never posts up here in this hellhole of debauchery.

Are not some of us curious folks here MODS?

With that said it's part of our jobs to help Dave in Clan Business...we are his true blue bitch elves.

mwhop78 wrote:

I don't think it matters one way or the other. The ones of us that play together do so regardless of what rosters we r on because we are all 30's. What i think might be the problem later or maybe already is dead weight that is taking up roster spots that never plays at all.

I basically havent played in a month so i guess im falling into the dead weight category. Am i going to be dropped from the roster if i dont play soon? Im tempted to pop the game in again but im just not sure i can pry BF3 out.

CrazyNixon7 wrote:

I basically havent played in a month so i guess im falling into the dead weight category. Am i going to be dropped from the roster if i dont play soon? Im tempted to pop the game in again but im just not sure i can pry BF3 out.

I don't want to be in that boat either. I don't have enough time for both games and find a higher level of satisfaction in BF3, but I miss playing with my brothers in Roster I. I would hate to get bumped off of Roster I.

@Manic, yes wer are Dave's little slaves and can move people around on the forums, but only the leader on elite can make any moves so the burden of this request will fall on him.

So we aren't doing the boobs thing anymore?

Boobs > FBD

He can give us access when needed...

Now no-one go all crazy about rosters...this is all just manChildren having a Think Tank so lets carry on...

So far Chris' idea is still the one that is holding my attention